Mark Minervini 2021: A Research Journal
Read the journey
September 24, 2021 · Tesla’s earnings were improving. The decision depended on a local setup during an unsettled market period.
A widely followed stock comes with more opinions than a trader can use. The practical question is narrower: after the base has formed, is there a specific place to enter and a specific price that would prove the entry wrong?
We stop at September 23 and open AlpharvestPro’s replay of that close. Prices are the archive’s revised split-adjusted units, not the literal quotes on the September 2021 tape.
What AlpharvestPro’s replay shows at the Sept. 23 close
AlpharvestPro’s history archive replays today’s presets, relative strength and Market Compass over 2020–2021 prices. It uses the current stock roster, so it carries survivorship bias. TSLA is here because it is one of Minervini’s 2021 setups, not because the app selected it. The replay shows how AlpharvestPro’s tools read the chart at the cutoff, not what any screen displayed in 2021 or what Minervini used.
| At the Sept. 23 close | AlpharvestPro replay |
|---|---|
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Uptrend Under Pressure since Sept. 10, inside an uptrend that had held since the S&P 500’s July 23 follow-through day. All five tracked indexes rose that day, and the Dow and NYSE Composite closed below their 50-day averages. |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed, current roster) | 78. Earlier readings: 71 on Aug. 25 (20 sessions before), 85 on June 24 (63 sessions) and 94 on March 25 (126 sessions); its range over the last 63 sessions was 59–87. |
| Price and averages | $251.21, above the 50-day average of $235.41 and above the 200-day average of $232.22. It closed 16.3% below its 52-week high of $300.13 on Jan. 25. |
| AlpharvestPro presets in the week before Sept. 24 | Five sessions, Sept. 17 to Sept. 23: AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, every session; AlpharvestPro Trend Template, every session; AlpharvestPro VCP Setup, every session; AlpharvestPro Late-Stage Failed Base, on Sept. 20, Sept. 21 and Sept. 23; AlpharvestPro Extreme Pullback, on Sept. 20, Sept. 21 and Sept. 22. These replays agree closely with the live app, except Extreme Pullback, which agrees moderately. Also shown, but not relied on because its replay agrees poorly with the live app: AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze, on Sept. 23. |
| AlpharvestPro presets the stock was on | AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, every session since Aug. 30; AlpharvestPro Trend Template, every session since Aug. 30; AlpharvestPro VCP Setup, every session since Aug. 30; AlpharvestPro Late-Stage Failed Base, every session since Sept. 23. All four replays agree closely with the live app. AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze also appears from Sept. 23, but its replay agrees poorly with the live app. |
| AlpharvestPro early-Stage-2 check | Not passed, on four conditions: its 150-day average had not been rising for long enough, the stock had already advanced far above its base low, its 52-week high was too old for the check and its RS was below the check’s own floor. |
| Industry peers | Auto Manufacturers: the two largest companies by today’s market value that traded then; the choice uses today’s knowledge, the readings do not. Toyota Motor Corporation (TM): RS 62; on AlpharvestPro Trend Template and Ichimoku Cloud Breakout; 1.7% below its 52-week high, above its 50-day average; up 3% over three months. Ferrari N.V. (RACE): RS 40; on no preset the replay relies on; 6.6% below its 52-week high, above its 50-day average; up 7% over three months. TSLA’s RS of 78 was above both. |
In the week before September 24, the replay showed two readings that pull in opposite directions. AlpharvestPro VCP Setup listed Tesla in every one of the five sessions, as it had since August 30, and AlpharvestPro Extreme Pullback listed it on September 20, 21 and 22. Yet AlpharvestPro Late-Stage Failed Base, a short-side preset, listed it on September 20, 21 and 23. The VCP Setup and Late-Stage Failed Base replays both agree closely with the live app. The replay does not say which reading was right; it shows that the same chart could be read both ways, a reason to define the risk before any trigger.
Tesla had only just come back onto AlpharvestPro’s trend presets. Both joined on August 30, after a base that fell about 40% from the January 25 high to $179.83 on March 5. The RS was recovering, from a low of 59 to 78, but it was not the dominant reading of earlier cases. Closer in, the stock pulled back about 6% from $254.82 on September 8 to $239.54 on September 20, and its last prior session’s high-to-low range was about 1.37%.
The market side was weaker: AlpharvestPro Market Compass had read Uptrend Under Pressure for two weeks, and two of the five tracked indexes were below their 50-day averages.
Agreement with the live app is the replay’s median daily overlap with the live AlpharvestPro app’s stored preset results from July 7 to November 6, 2026. A preset with low agreement is shown when it appears, but it is not relied on.
Prior-close market and screening context · 2021-09-23
| SPY adjusted close | +0.37% versus its 50-session average |
| VIX close | 18.63 |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed) | 78 · current stored roster, not a 2021 published ranking |
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Uptrend Under Pressure |
| AlpharvestPro presets (33 of 36; 3 left out for near-zero agreement) | 4 of 25 evaluated at close or moderate agreement listed the stock; 1 of 8 at low agreement, shown but not relied on; 0 could not be evaluated |
Retrospective context. Compass headlines and preset membership have unresolved validation limits; distribution-day counts and broad breadth classifications are withheld. No screen output proves a historical order or full SEPA qualification.
The information already public
Tesla’s July 26 release and quarterly update reported second-quarter revenue of $11.96 billion and about $1.14 billion in GAAP net income attributable to common shareholders. The quarterly filing provides the detailed figures.
The market also had the September 22 FOMC statement, which said a moderation in asset purchases might soon be warranted if progress continued. That was a change to consider in the background, not a causal explanation for a particular Tesla order.
The proposed VCP interpretation emphasizes narrowing price ranges near the right side. Average volume over the last five sessions was roughly 1.06 times the trailing 50-session average. That broader comparison does not support describing the entire approach as an extreme volume dry-up. Total volume also does not directly identify selling pressure.


| SEPA element | Evidence at September 23 | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Trend | AlpharvestPro RS 78; on AlpharvestPro RS Leaders and Trend Template since Aug. 30; early-Stage-2 check not passed. | Supported, moderate relative leadership |
| Fundamentals | July 26: revenue and substantial GAAP profitability reported. | Supported operating strength |
| Catalyst | Operating progress and changing policy context already public. | Specific order motive unknown |
| Entry | Narrow final daily range; broader five-session volume not unusually low. | Conditional contraction interpretation |
| Exit | No documented stop or actual sales. | Unknown |
Trade the local structure
The teaching plan uses Minervini’s structure with our own fixed conventions. After the September 20 shakeout, Tesla’s final contraction, September 21 to 23, was 3.7% deep and sat 0.8% below the September 8 base high. The trigger sits one cent above that contraction’s high, at $252.74, and the stop one cent below its low, at $243.47. The 3.67% distance, inside Minervini’s 10% ceiling, permits 43 shares and $10,867.82 of adjusted-unit exposure. These prices incorporate later splits and are not the literal quotes seen on the September 2021 tape.
| Teaching calculation | Archive-adjusted units |
|---|---|
| Final contraction | 2021-09-21 to 2021-09-23 |
| Illustrative account / risk budget | $40,000 / $400 (1%) |
| Conditional trigger / stop | $252.74 / $243.47 |
| Risk per share / distance | $9.27 / 3.67%, within Minervini’s 10% ceiling |
| Whole shares / planned stop loss | 43 / $398.61 |
| Position value / account exposure | $10,867.82 / 27.17% |
A teaching calculation with fixed conventions of our own: trigger 1¢ beyond the final contraction’s high (low for a short) and stop 1¢ beyond its other side, read from bars up to the cutoff, sized so the loss at the stop stays within $400. The 10% ceiling is Minervini’s: “keep your losses to 10 percent or less” (Think & Trade Like a Champion).
A conditional plan would require a controlled move through the chosen level, recalculate after a gap, and exit on structural failure. AlpharvestPro Market Compass was under pressure, so a trader would also examine the market evidence rather than assume that a famous leader guaranteed favorable conditions.
Once the stock advanced, the chosen profit-protection rule would need to specify how much room a normal pullback deserved. If the trade works, the exit scenario in the reveal applies fixed rules adapted from Minervini’s guidance in Think & Trade Like a Champion: the stop moves to breakeven once the price has risen three times the risk, and once the 50-day average catches up with the entry, a close below it ends the trade. It is a teaching rule, not proof of Minervini’s historical rule for this position.
Your decision: does the final pause provide enough local control, and what broader market evidence would you require before taking the planned size?
Reveal the later Tesla path

September 24 closed at about $258.13 on the revised basis. The archive later reached $414.50 on November 4 and ended the year at $352.26. The advance was substantial, with a meaningful decline from the later high.
AlpharvestPro at the September 24 close. The S&P 500 rose 0.15%; AlpharvestPro Market Compass read Uptrend Under Pressure. TSLA’s AlpharvestPro RS rose to 79. It dropped AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze and AlpharvestPro Late-Stage Failed Base. TSLA rose 2.8% on 1.18 times its average daily volume over the previous 50 sessions.
Those prices can test a written management rule. They do not show that Minervini captured the whole move or sold at its peak. The actual entry, additions, partial sales, and realized result remain unavailable.
| Hypothetical exit scenario | Through December 31, 2021 |
|---|---|
| Entry | 2021-09-24 at $252.74 |
| Initial stop | $243.47 |
| Stop changes | 2021-10-15: stop raised to breakeven; 2021-10-21: 50-day average reached the entry |
| Exit | 2021-12-13 at $322.14 (close below the 50-day average) |
| Result | +27.46% · +7.49 R · +$2,984.06 on 43 shares |
Fixed rules adapted from Minervini’s guidance in Think & Trade Like a Champion: the initial stop; the stop to breakeven once the price has moved three times the risk; and, once the 50-day average reaches the entry, an exit on a close beyond it (“breakeven or better”). Selling into strength is not modelled. Our conventions: a stop change takes effect from the next session; an exit on a close is valued at that close; an entry that opens past the trigger is resized to keep the $400 risk. Daily bars cannot show the order of moves within a day. R is the initial risk per share. A teaching scenario, not Minervini’s trade; no costs, borrow or slippage.
For the next well-known stock on your list, hide the name and read AlpharvestPro’s replay first: how long the stock has been on the trend presets, where its RS is heading, and what Market Compass says. Then mark the local failure level, restore the name, and check whether the narrative changed your willingness to obey that level.
Sources: Minervini, Think & Trade Like a Champion (exit-scenario rules); Tesla July 26, 2021 update and Q2 filing; FOMC statement, September 22; Minervini, Trade Like a Stock Market Wizard, Chapters 3 and 10. Chart, volume, RS, presets and Market Compass: AlpharvestPro history archive replay at September 23, with later adjustment revisions and no authenticated executions.
AlpharvestPro wrote and published this independent research journal. AlpharvestPro is not affiliated with or endorsed by Mark Minervini.