Mark Minervini 2021: A Research Journal
Read the journey
February 9, 2021 · Rare-earth demand offered a compelling business narrative. The recent listing history limited what a standard long-term screen could tell us.
A stock associated with a major industrial transition can feel as though it comes with its own explanation. MP Materials connected rare-earth production with electrification, but the theme did not determine whether February 9 was a controlled place to enter.
The cutoff is February 8, and we open AlpharvestPro’s replay of that close. The archive supplies 160 valid prior bars. Some of that price history precedes the completed business combination, so it should not be treated as 160 sessions of the same operating company’s public-market record.
What AlpharvestPro’s replay shows at the Feb. 8 close
AlpharvestPro’s history archive replays today’s presets, relative strength and Market Compass over 2020–2021 prices. It uses the current stock roster, so it carries survivorship bias. MP is here because it is one of Minervini’s 2021 setups, not because the app selected it. The replay shows how AlpharvestPro’s tools read the chart at the cutoff, not what any screen displayed in 2021 or what Minervini used.
| At the Feb. 8 close | AlpharvestPro replay |
|---|---|
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Confirmed Uptrend. The uptrend had held since the S&P 500’s Nov. 4, 2020 follow-through day, with one session at Uptrend Under Pressure on Jan. 29. All five tracked indexes rose that day and closed at new highs. |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed, current roster) | No reading. MP’s 160 sessions were fewer than AlpharvestPro’s RS ranking needs. |
| Price and averages | $32.56, above the 50-day average near $30.02. There was not yet enough history for a 200-day average. |
| AlpharvestPro presets in the week before Feb. 9 | None. In the five sessions from Feb. 2 to Feb. 8 most presets were still unknown for a stock this young, and the replay showed it on none of the others. |
| AlpharvestPro presets the stock was on | None. A stock this young had too little history for 27 of the 33 presets, which are unknown, not failed; the replay did not show it on any of the other 6. |
| Industry peers | Other Industrial Metals & Mining: the two largest companies by today’s market value that traded then; the choice uses today’s knowledge, the readings do not. BHP Group Limited (BHP): RS 61; on AlpharvestPro Trend Template; 6.4% below its 52-week high, above its 50-day average; up 39% over three months. Rio Tinto Plc (RIO): RS 65; on AlpharvestPro Trend Template and AVWAP Pullback Watch; 7.6% below its 52-week high, above its 50-day average; up 37% over three months. MP had no RS reading to compare. |
The market backdrop was strong, with every tracked index at a new high, but the replay cannot say whether AlpharvestPro would have shown MP. The chart shows a base forming below the December 22 high of $40.74. MP pulled back about 30% to $28.36 on January 4, rallied to $36.80 on January 20, fell about 23% to $28.20 on January 27, and then tightened: from a February 4 high of $34.48 to a low of $31.26 on February 8, about 9%. At the cutoff the close was 20.1% below the December high.
Shrinking pullbacks are the shape Minervini looks for. A recovery and a relevant industrial theme could justify placing MP on a research list. Calling it a fully confirmed SEPA candidate would require more than those observations.
Prior-close market and screening context · 2021-02-08
| SPY adjusted close | +4.59% versus its 50-session average |
| VIX close | 21.24 |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed) | Unavailable · current stored roster, not a 2021 published ranking |
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Confirmed Uptrend |
| AlpharvestPro presets (33 of 36; 3 left out for near-zero agreement) | 0 of 4 evaluated at close or moderate agreement listed the stock; 0 of 2 at low agreement, shown but not relied on; 27 could not be evaluated |
Retrospective context. Compass headlines and preset membership have unresolved validation limits; distribution-day counts and broad breadth classifications are withheld. No screen output proves a historical order or full SEPA qualification.
What the screen could not show
MP’s November 23, 2020 release reported third-quarter revenue of $41.0 million, up 52%, and net income of $14.6 million. Adjusted EBITDA rose to $11.6 million. The revenue figure included an $8.9 million tariff refund; the adjusted EBITDA calculation excluded that benefit.
That detail changes the quality of the comparison. A trader could recognize improved economics without assuming every dollar of reported revenue represented repeatable demand growth. The release also described the completed business combination and investment plans, giving a dated basis for the electrification-related thesis.
There was also a supply question. On December 9, MP filed a registration statement covering the resale of 118,047,154 shares by existing holders and up to 11,499,968 shares issuable on exercise of warrants. Registered shares can reach the market once their holders are free to sell, so the filing was part of the setup a trader had to weigh, not a footnote.


| SEPA element | Available evidence | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Trend | Feb. 8 close above the 50-day average; no 200-day average, AlpharvestPro RS or preset readings. | Partial support |
| Fundamentals | Nov. 23 release: profitable quarter, revenue growth with a tariff-refund contribution. | Supported improvement; composition matters |
| Catalyst | Electrification supply-chain strategy described publicly; Dec. 9 resale registration added potential supply. | Supported theme, not guaranteed result |
| Entry | Date under review exists; actual trigger and fill do not. | Conditional reconstruction |
| Exit | No execution-linked stop or sale record. | Unknown |
A risk plan for a developing chart
The teaching plan uses Minervini’s structure with our own fixed conventions. After the February 1–4 rally, MP paused for three sessions, February 4 to 8, in a 9.3% range, still 15.4% below its December 22 high. The trigger sits one cent above the pause high, at $34.49, and the stop one cent below its low, at $31.25. This is a 9.39% initial distance, just inside his 10% ceiling. The illustrative position is 123 shares, about $4,242 in value, with $398.52 of planned loss before costs and slippage.
| Teaching calculation | Archive-adjusted units |
|---|---|
| Final contraction | 2021-02-04 to 2021-02-08 |
| Illustrative account / risk budget | $40,000 / $400 (1%) |
| Conditional trigger / stop | $34.49 / $31.25 |
| Risk per share / distance | $3.24 / 9.39%, within Minervini’s 10% ceiling |
| Whole shares / planned stop loss | 123 / $398.52 |
| Position value / account exposure | $4,242.27 / 10.61% |
A teaching calculation with fixed conventions of our own: trigger 1¢ beyond the final contraction’s high (low for a short) and stop 1¢ beyond its other side, read from bars up to the cutoff, sized so the loss at the stop stays within $400. The 10% ceiling is Minervini’s: “keep your losses to 10 percent or less” (Think & Trade Like a Champion).
A plausible decision under the documented emphasis on entry and exit planning would be conditional: buy only if the price crosses the selected trigger in an acceptable range, or wait for tighter action. If a catalyst causes a large opening gap, recalculate or pass. A favorable long-term narrative would not justify moving the initial stop down.
For a position that develops an early gain, the trader must also choose a profit-protection rule before the gain becomes emotionally difficult to surrender. If the trade works, the exit scenario in the reveal applies fixed rules adapted from Minervini’s guidance in Think & Trade Like a Champion: the stop moves to breakeven once the price has risen three times the risk, and once the 50-day average catches up with the entry, a close below it ends the trade. It is a teaching rule here, not evidence of Minervini’s actual MP exit.
Your decision: does the available evidence support a small conditional trade, or should the missing history keep the candidate on the watchlist?
Reveal the later MP chart

February 9 reached $36.55 and closed at $35.56, up 9.2% on 1.86 times its average daily volume over the previous 50 sessions. The close cleared the February 4 high but remained 12.7% below the December high. MP later reached $51.77 on March 2, fell to $23.18 on May 13, and ended the year at $45.42. In the exit scenario below, the stop moved to breakeven on February 19 and the February 23 decline ended the trade at the entry price; the March 30 range later crossed the original $31.25 stop.
AlpharvestPro at the February 9 close. AlpharvestPro Market Compass read Confirmed Uptrend. The S&P 500 and Dow slipped, while the Nasdaq Composite, NYSE Composite and Russell closed at new highs. The replay still had no RS reading for MP and showed it on no preset, with most presets still unknown.
That path demonstrates why “the company eventually recovered” is an inadequate exit rule. A trader might have taken profits, raised a stop, exited, or later re-entered. The available evidence does not identify which actions Minervini took, and the later recovery cannot validate holding through every decline.
| Hypothetical exit scenario | Through December 31, 2021 |
|---|---|
| Entry | 2021-02-09 at $34.49 |
| Initial stop | $31.25 |
| Stop changes | 2021-02-19: stop raised to breakeven |
| Exit | 2021-02-23 at $34.49 (breakeven stop) |
| Result | +0.00% · +0.00 R · +$0.00 on 123 shares |
Fixed rules adapted from Minervini’s guidance in Think & Trade Like a Champion: the initial stop; the stop to breakeven once the price has moved three times the risk; and, once the 50-day average reaches the entry, an exit on a close beyond it (“breakeven or better”). Selling into strength is not modelled. Our conventions: a stop change takes effect from the next session; an exit on a close is valued at that close; an entry that opens past the trigger is resized to keep the $400 risk. Daily bars cannot show the order of moves within a day. R is the initial risk per share. A teaching scenario, not Minervini’s trade; no costs, borrow or slippage.
MP’s lesson is to separate a durable theme from a temporary position. When AlpharvestPro’s replay has nothing to say about a new listing, the chart and the filings have to carry the case: record the business thesis, the share supply you know about, and the price evidence required to keep the trade. One should not silently replace the other when price turns down.
Corporate sources: MP Materials release, November 23, 2020; MP Materials Form S-1, December 9, 2020. Method: Minervini, Trade Like a Stock Market Wizard, Chapter 3. Chart, presets and Market Compass: AlpharvestPro history archive replay; short listing history limits qualification. The entry and stop are reconstructed from the chart, not verified orders.
AlpharvestPro wrote and published this independent research journal. AlpharvestPro is not affiliated with or endorsed by Mark Minervini.