Mark Minervini 2021: A Research Journal
Read the journey
September 1, 2021 · Penske Automotive offered strong reported earnings and an improving chart. The first test was whether the local structure could hold.
A good business and a good entry are separate questions. PAG puts them side by side: strong reported earnings, an improving chart, and a short-term plan that has to stand on its own stop.
The company in this case is Penske Automotive Group, NYSE:PAG. Its July 28 earnings release confirms the identity. Penn National Gaming’s August 5 release identifies the separate NASDAQ:PENN business. The two tickers must not share a chart or earnings narrative. Our cutoff is August 31, and we open AlpharvestPro’s replay of that close.
What AlpharvestPro’s replay shows at the Aug. 31 close
AlpharvestPro’s history archive replays today’s presets, relative strength and Market Compass over 2020–2021 prices. It uses the current stock roster, so it carries survivorship bias. PAG is here because it is one of Minervini’s 2021 setups, not because the app selected it. The replay shows how AlpharvestPro’s tools read the chart at the cutoff, not what any screen displayed in 2021 or what Minervini used.
| At the Aug. 31 close | AlpharvestPro replay |
|---|---|
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Confirmed Uptrend. The uptrend had held since the S&P 500’s July 23 follow-through day, with three sessions at Uptrend Under Pressure along the way, the latest on Aug. 20. The tracked indexes were mixed that day, but all five closed above their 50- and 200-day averages. |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed, current roster) | 83. Earlier readings: 82 on Aug. 3 (20 sessions before), 80 on June 2 (63 sessions) and 71 on March 3 (126 sessions); its range over the last 63 sessions was 63–84. |
| Price and averages | $79.55, above the 50-day average of $72.88 and above the 200-day average of $66.03. It closed 2.8% below its 52-week high of $81.82 on May 10. |
| AlpharvestPro presets in the week before Sept. 1 | Five sessions, Aug. 25 to Aug. 31: AlpharvestPro Near 52-Week High, every session; AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, every session; AlpharvestPro Trend Template, every session. Each of these replays agrees closely with the live app. Also shown, but not relied on because its replay agrees poorly with the live app: AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze, on Aug. 31. |
| AlpharvestPro presets the stock was on | AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, every session since July 29; AlpharvestPro Trend Template, every session since Sept. 28, 2020; AlpharvestPro Near 52-Week High, every session since July 29. All three replays agree closely with the live app. AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze also appears from Aug. 31, but its replay agrees poorly with the live app. |
| AlpharvestPro early-Stage-2 check | Not passed, on two conditions: its 150-day average had been rising for longer than an early-stage advance and the stock had already advanced far above its base low. |
| Industry peers | Auto & Truck Dealerships: the two largest companies by today’s market value that traded then; the choice uses today’s knowledge, the readings do not. Carvana Co. (CVNA): RS 73; on AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, Trend Template and Extreme Pullback; 12.9% below its 52-week high, below its 50-day average; up 18% over three months. CarMax Inc (KMX): RS 51; on no preset the replay relies on; 10.5% below its 52-week high, below its 50-day average; up 9% over three months. PAG’s RS of 83 was above both. |
PAG rejoined AlpharvestPro RS Leaders on July 29, the session after its earnings release, after a single day off the list, and had stayed on the Trend Template for almost a year. The base was orderly: from the May 10 high it fell about 22% to $63.67 on June 18, jumped 7.4% on July 29, reached $80.11 on August 3, pulled back about 8% to $73.85 on August 19, and closed August within 3% of the May high.
Agreement with the live app is the replay’s median daily overlap with the live AlpharvestPro app’s stored preset results from July 7 to November 6, 2026. A preset with low agreement is shown when it appears, but it is not relied on.
Prior-close market and screening context · 2021-08-31
| SPY adjusted close | +3.11% versus its 50-session average |
| VIX close | 16.48 |
| AlpharvestPro RS (reconstructed) | 83 · current stored roster, not a 2021 published ranking |
| AlpharvestPro Market Compass (provisional) | Confirmed Uptrend |
| AlpharvestPro presets (33 of 36; 3 left out for near-zero agreement) | 3 of 25 evaluated at close or moderate agreement listed the stock; 1 of 8 at low agreement, shown but not relied on; 0 could not be evaluated |
Retrospective context. Compass headlines and preset membership have unresolved validation limits; distribution-day counts and broad breadth classifications are withheld. No screen output proves a historical order or full SEPA qualification.
What was known at August 31
Penske reported second-quarter revenue of $7.0 billion, up 91.4%, and continuing-operations EPS of $4.20, versus $0.56. Adjusted continuing-operations EPS was $4.47. The release also provided comparisons against 2019, useful for assessing performance beyond the depressed 2020 base, and noted a higher quarterly dividend and a larger repurchase authorization.
The proposed chart interpretation is a contraction as price works up the right side of a base. Quiet action can support that reading, but a low-volume bar alone cannot identify institutional accumulation or prove the whole base is a VCP. The actual pivot and contraction boundaries still need to be specified.


| SEPA element | Evidence at August 31 | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Trend | AlpharvestPro RS 83; on AlpharvestPro RS Leaders, Trend Template and Near 52-Week High. | Supported |
| Fundamentals | July 28: strong sales and continuing-operations earnings; GAAP and adjusted measures separate. | Supported |
| Catalyst | Automotive-retail operating improvement already public. | Business context supported; trade motive unknown |
| Entry | Right-side contraction hypothesis; no authenticated order price. | Conditional |
| Exit | No verified stop or sale. | Unknown |
Define failure while the thesis is attractive
The teaching plan uses Minervini’s structure with our own fixed conventions. PAG’s final three sessions, August 27 to 31, formed a 3.8% area 1.3% below the August 2 base high. The trigger sits one cent above that area, at $79.87, and the stop one cent below it, at $76.82: a 3.82% distance, inside Minervini’s 10% ceiling. A $400 budget permits 131 shares and $10,462.97 of adjusted-unit exposure, with $399.55 of planned initial loss before costs and gaps.
| Teaching calculation | Archive-adjusted units |
|---|---|
| Final contraction | 2021-08-27 to 2021-08-31 |
| Illustrative account / risk budget | $40,000 / $400 (1%) |
| Conditional trigger / stop | $79.87 / $76.82 |
| Risk per share / distance | $3.05 / 3.82%, within Minervini’s 10% ceiling |
| Whole shares / planned stop loss | 131 / $399.55 |
| Position value / account exposure | $10,462.97 / 26.16% |
A teaching calculation with fixed conventions of our own: trigger 1¢ beyond the final contraction’s high (low for a short) and stop 1¢ beyond its other side, read from bars up to the cutoff, sized so the loss at the stop stays within $400. The 10% ceiling is Minervini’s: “keep your losses to 10 percent or less” (Think & Trade Like a Champion).
A conditional plan would act only on a controlled trigger and exit if the local failure level traded. A strong earnings release would not authorize widening the stop. Re-entry, if justified later, would require a fresh setup and a separate decision.
This follows the distinction in Minervini’s advance-planning discussion: an initial stop and a plan for considering the stock again are separate rules. The possibility of a later recovery is not an initial risk-management rule.
Your decision: would you take this local trigger, and would you still honor the chosen failure level if the business news remained favorable?
Reveal the later PAG path

September 1 opened at about $80.04 in adjusted units, above the $79.87 trigger, and reached approximately $80.75. The exit scenario buys at that open and recalculates the order from 131 to 124 shares to keep the $400 risk. The September 3 daily range crossed the $76.82 stop. A plan genuinely using that initial stop could not claim the later peak as its holding result: the exit scenario below takes the loss, one times the risk.
AlpharvestPro at the September 1 close. The S&P 500 rose 0.03%; AlpharvestPro Market Compass read Confirmed Uptrend. PAG’s AlpharvestPro RS stayed at 83. It dropped AlpharvestPro NR7 Squeeze. PAG fell 0.3% on 1.87 times its average daily volume over the previous 50 sessions.
Heavy volume without upward progress on September 1 preceded the stop. PAG later reached about $101.15 on October 26 and ended the year near $95.24. These later prices do not invalidate a disciplined early exit, and they do not identify Minervini’s actions. His actual stop and realized result remain unknown.
| Hypothetical exit scenario | Through December 31, 2021 |
|---|---|
| Entry | 2021-09-01 at $80.04 (the open, past the trigger; resized from 131 to 124 shares so the initial risk, $399.44, stays within $400) |
| Initial stop | $76.82 |
| Stop changes | none |
| Exit | 2021-09-03 at $76.82 (initial stop) |
| Result | −4.02% · −1.00 R · −$399.44 on 124 shares |
Fixed rules adapted from Minervini’s guidance in Think & Trade Like a Champion: the initial stop; the stop to breakeven once the price has moved three times the risk; and, once the 50-day average reaches the entry, an exit on a close beyond it (“breakeven or better”). Selling into strength is not modelled. Our conventions: a stop change takes effect from the next session; an exit on a close is valued at that close; an entry that opens past the trigger is resized to keep the $400 risk. Daily bars cannot show the order of moves within a day. R is the initial risk per share. A teaching scenario, not Minervini’s trade; no costs, borrow or slippage.
PAG’s lesson is to judge the entry and the company separately. A stock that sits on every AlpharvestPro trend preset still has to pass the first test of a local entry. Write down the stop you would obey while you still like the earnings story, and treat any later setup as a new decision.
Sources: Penske release, July 28, 2021; Penn National release, August 5, for identity only; Minervini, Think & Trade Like a Champion, Section 1. Chart, RS, presets and Market Compass: AlpharvestPro history archive replay. Dates and price paths are research observations, not authenticated executions. Prices use later dividend adjustments, and the case was selected retrospectively.
AlpharvestPro wrote and published this independent research journal. AlpharvestPro is not affiliated with or endorsed by Mark Minervini.